9 in 10 Americans take fraud precautions, yet 1 in 3 is scammed

Personal vigilance alone can't protect consumers when the system lacks embedded trust infrastructure. Invela examines Bankrate's fraud survey.

Published:  

January 14, 2026
2

min  

9 in 10 Americans take fraud precautions, yet 1 in 3 is scammed

Key takeaways

  • Bankrate's survey found 89% of Americans took concrete steps to protect themselves last year.
  • Yet 1 in 3 was still scammed in the same 12 months, and 37% of those victims lost money.
  • Most fraud risk now sits in the seams between institutions, intermediaries and third-party providers.
  • Open finance risk management needs standardised accreditation, dynamic risk monitoring and an insurance-backed warranty.

Americans are more vigilant than ever. According to Bankrate's fraud survey, 89% of people took concrete steps last year to protect themselves – updating passwords, enabling two-factor authentication, monitoring accounts, shredding documents, and avoiding suspicious links.

And yet, despite this unprecedented level of personal vigilance, 1 in 3 Americans was still scammed in that same 12 month period. Worse, 37% of those victims lost money.

This is the paradox at the heart of today's financial ecosystem. Consumers are doing more. Fraudsters are doing more. But the infrastructure in between – the systems that govern account access, data sharing, and third-party connectivity – hasn't kept pace.

The real problem isn't consumer behaviour – it's systemic exposure

When 68% of Americans have experienced a financial scam at some point in their lives, it's not a story about individual responsibility. It's a story about structural risk. Every new fintech app, data aggregator, payment initiator, and financial service provider introduces a new connection point – and with it, a new vulnerability. Most fraud risk now sits in the seams between institutions, intermediaries, and third-party providers.

Open finance needs a new risk model

Open banking promised secure, permissioned data sharing. Open finance expands that promise – but also expands the attack surface. Fraudsters are exploiting the weakest link in the chain – and it's rarely the consumer.

What modern Open Finance Risk Management looks like

1. Standardised accreditation of third-party providers – only trusted, verified organisations should be able to gain access to customer accounts and financial data.

2. Dynamic monitoring of risk indicators – real-time detection of anomalies, behavioural risk signals, and suspicious patterns across third-party connections.

3. Insurance-backed warranty model – a tangible safeguard that reduces risk between banks and fintechs, turning assurance into something measurable, not theoretical.

Consumers can't solve this alone. Banks can't solve it alone. Intermediaries can't solve it alone. Fintechs can't solve it alone. But the ecosystem can – with Open Finance Risk Management. Fraud is no longer a personal problem. It's an ecosystem problem. And ecosystem problems require ecosystem solutions.

Invela INSIGHTS Blog

Open finance, explained

Insight on accreditation, risk scoring and warranty for banks, intermediaries and third parties.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Louise Beaumont
Written by
Head of Marketing, Communications & Design

Louise Beaumont leads marketing, communications and design at Invela, with 30+ years in tech and fintech and 15+ in open banking and open finance.

Connect on LinkedIn